Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Veronica McKendry's avatar

I love it. As soon as I saw him, before even reading the post, I knew he had to be a musketeer!

Expand full comment
Fae's avatar

What if I told you that Porthos isn't supposed to be 'portly' at all? (And therefore you have made a most splendid rendition. 10/10.) In the book, Porthos is described as "of great height and haughty countenance" but straight after Aramis is described as "a stout man," so I'm going to guess that the two get conflated. Meanwhile Porthos is based off of the real life Isaac de *Porthau.* I wasn't able to find much on whether or not either of the names suggest 'portly' as they do in English, but it is definitely a misnomer according to Dumas' description. There are lots of depictions of Porthos being the heaviest-set of the lot (namely the 1993 film adaptation, for recent memory) with more recent adaptations going for the giant-of-a-man idea. Personally, this is my favorite illustration of Porthos!

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts